|
Final
TOWN OF ROSENDALE
PLANNING BOARD MINUTES
Nov 5, 2009
Acting Chairman Joe Havranek called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm at the Rosendale Community Center, Rosendale, NY.
ROLL CALL; Chairman Billy Liggan- Excused
Randi Morf -
Present
Jeanne Walsh -
Present
Fred Greitzer -
Present
John McEnrue -
Excused
Peter Perry -
Present
Joseph Havranek -
Present
Nick Mercurio -
Present
Dave Plante, C.T. Male Assoc. Present
Also Present: F Stop Town Board Liaison
Minutes:
The minutes from Oct 1, 2009 meeting were reviewed and accepted as written.
Motion made by J Walsh, seconded by R.Morf
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes,– Peter Perry -Abstained
Motion Carried.
Public Hearing:
Gallagher – Special Use Permit #2009-8
Open P/H 7:35 p.m.
Closed P/H 7:40 p.m.
Public Comments were from Doug Motel
– Stated he is the closest neighbor and he likes the idea of having
goats and chickens instead of the previous application for that
property.
No other comments were taken from the public
Motion was made by F.Greitzer to close the Public Hearing, seconded by P. Perry.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion was made by R. Morf, seconded by P.Perry for final approval for the Special Use permit submitted by the Gallagher’s.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes Motion Carried.
Motion was made by F.Greitzer, seconded by P.Perry to approve the Site Plan for March and Timothy Gallagher reference #2009-8.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes Motion Carried
Landau - Special Use Permit # 2009-10
Open P/H 7:45 p.m.
Closed P/H 7:48 p.m.
Maylie’s (neighbors)
were not in attendance but would like the following comments added to
the records. “Just to let you know, we have talked to our neighbors
about their application for change use and we are satisfied on what they
plan to do. We will be in Florida during the public hearing”. Received by email on Oct 28, 2009.
No other comments from the Public.
Motion was made by F. Greitzer, seconded by N. Mercurio to close the Public Hearing
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes Motion Carried
Questions were asked by
the board on lighting issues concerning the sign. Applicants have
talked to the Building Inspector concerning permit.
Motion was made by P.Perry, seconded by F.Greitzer for conditional approval for Site Plan #2009-10.
Conditions are: if the
applicant decides to add lighting to the sign, they will need to come
back to the Planning Board for an amended Site plan to include cut sheet
for proposed lighting (for the sign)
Motion was made by P.Perry, seconded by R. Morf for approval of Special Use Permit.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes Motion Carried
Old Business:
Swarthout – Lotline Adjustment #2009-9
Deed language needed from Mr. Swarthout and Neighbor
New Business:
Rowe – Minor Subdivision #2009-11
For the record application should be a Major Subdivision because of the amount of lots involved in project.
Applicant to amend application and plat to read Major Subdivision
Cemetery on applicant’s property buffer line around Cemetery needs to be added to Plat
Deed lines need to be added to Plat
Wetlands need to be delineated on Plat (inset map)
Perk data and Board of Health approval required
Road access – Letter to Town Highway Super, find out if Curb cut is required
Second Deed for property. All items required to be submitted by Nov 19, 2009
Motion made by P.Perry,
seconded by J. Walsh to classify the project as a Unlisted Action
pursuant to Section 617.5(c)(3) of SEQRA.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Opposed, Joseph Havranek -
Yes, Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion was made by P.Perry, seconded by F.Greitzer to schedule a Public Hearing for the next meeting in December.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Marshke – Minor Subdivision #2009-12
Represented by Don Brewer
Septic and well need to be moved at least 200 ft from each other when the septic field is uphill from the well.
Motion made by F. Greitzer, seconded by P.Perry to declare Planning Board as the Lead Agency under SEQRA
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion made by F. Greitzer, seconded by P.Perry to classify project as an Unlisted action pursuant to SEQRA.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion was made by F. Greitzer, seconded by P.Perry to schedule a Public Hearing for December 3rd
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes , Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Short EAF read by Randi Morf for the Record
Mr. Marshke needs to sign the Short EAF form for the file
Dietz – Major Subdivision #2009-14
After decision with the Planning board – Mrs. Dietz decided to table the subdivision at this time
Dietz Special Use / Site Plan #2009-15
Building Inspector needs to sign off application
County Board of Health approval needed for the septic and well.
RMA needed from neighbors concerning Eddy Lane
Motion was made by F.Greitzer, seconded by P.Perry to classify the project as Type II action pursuant to SEQRA.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek - Yes,
Nick Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion was made by F.Greitzer, seconded by J. Walsh to schedule a Public Hearing for December 3, 2009
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek Yes, Nick
Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Kong – Ricci Lot line Adjustment #2009-16
Need a letter form both parties saying they are in agreement with the Lotline adjustment
Deed description needed to include Mr. Ricci property
Map that was presented to the board did not show both lots involved surveyed.
Drinking wells / septic reserve and adjacent properties need to be shown on map.
Motion was made by J. Havranek, seconded by F.Greitzer to classify project as a Type II action pursuant to SEQRA.
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek Yes, Nick
Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Motion was made by F. Greitzer, seconded by P. Perry to waive the Public Hearing
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek Yes, Nick
Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Correspondence:
None
Misc. Business:
Board is requesting from Lawyer correspondence concerning the dates for the lawsuit Clerk will contact Marylou.
Board has concerns
about the decision concerning Aerostar. Request that Dave Massimi and
Marylou attend the next workshop meeting @6:30 pm Dec 3.
Fred requested clerk to
contact Dept of State Commissioner on Open Government regarding
executive session , is it legal to do with Lawyer present
Motion to adjourn the meeting @ 10:35 pm by F.Greitzer seconded by R.Morf
Roll Vote: Randi Morf
–Yes, Jeanne Walsh – Yes, Fred Greitzer – Yes, Joseph Havranek Yes, Nick
Mercurio - Yes, – Peter Perry –Yes
Motion Carried
Leslie Treut
Planning Board Clerk
| 
